December 12, 2001

Narrative Journalism Comes of Age

Recently a group of distinguished storytellers traveled to Cambridge, Mass., to coach their peers in the craft, the professional challenges, and the ethical considerations of narrative journalism.

Several audience members supplied this joint Nieman-Poynter project with informal "letters to colleagues" recounting the practical and professional advice served in the sessions. These letters are the first fruits of the workshop, from which more and better narrative writing may flow.

THE NEXT GENERATION OF NARRATIVE JOURNALISM

Excerpts from Mark Kramer's closing essay:

"The second stage of narrative journalism involves finding useful and comfortable ways in-house of adjusting to the uneven scheduling of narrative writers' time, finding space, finding and assigning flexibly the attention of those editors who can best handle this special copy. 

"... the second stage also involves coming to more sophisticated realizations of what narrative is for. Later serials take on less lurid but more complex subjects ... and they require greater technical proficiency in narrative writing in order to sustain reader-interest."

WRITING A GOOD STORY

• The hardest part is getting started. Chip Scanlan advises writers to abandon their standards, and just start writing.
• Isabel Wilkerson explains the importance of the face-to-face conversation, and lists the seven phases of the interview.
• The three most beautiful words in the English language, says Tom French, are "to be continued." Each good story has an engine, an unanswered question that pulls the reader through.
• Mark Kramer offers 10 ways to build a compelling experience for the reader; For example, finding hints of personality in each character.
• Great stories don't require larger-than-life characters. Gay Talese made a brilliant career of his interest in the lives of everyday people.
• Choose your words carefully, says Emily Hiestand. Describe your subject before you write about it.
• Set each story as a three-act drama, says Nora Ephron. Force yourself to identify the beginning, middle, and end.
• Joe Franklin adds fiction writing doesn't have a monopoly on elements like character, rhythm, and plot.
• Ira Glass sets three requirements for each of his stories. The first is that there must be at least one moment of amusement that belongs to him.
• If the all of these rules and techniques leave you dry, try Rick Bragg's no-nonsense advice: just tell a good story.

TELLING WITH PICTURES
• Stan Grossfeld bravely tells a room full of writers that their word-controlled world is wrong. Storytellers, he says, should know how to use both pictures and words.
• David Fanning warns that too many TV news segments are created by finding compelling pictures and then writing words to match them. Never write for the pictures, he says. Write for the story.
THE SPACE BETWEEN FACT AND FICTION

• Sometimes narrative journalism seems too detailed to be true. Adam Hochschild reassures us that accuracy is just as important in narrative as in hard news.
• "Everything is a Rorschach," declares Nora Ephron, who says she lost faith in journalism when she realized that each person might find a different truth in the same collection of facts.

WORKING NARRATIVE INTO YOUR JOB

• Bob Batz of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette recommends that reporters and photographers form "Subversive Writers' Groups" to promote narrative journalism in their organizations.
• How can you convince your editor that newspapers need need narrative? Jack Hart has a 10-step plan for making your case -- and winning a Pulitzer.
• Jacqui Banaszynski offers to help editors and reporters get along.

WORKSHOP ROUNDUP
Redefining Narrative
By Mark Kramer
SESSION REVIEWS
Nora Ephron
Telling the Story
Bob Batz, Angela Pancrazio
The Subversive Writers' Group
Gay Talese
Suggestions for Daily Journalists
David Fanning
TV Documentary
Mark Kramer
A Notebook Full of Narrative
Nan Talese, Stuart O'Nan
Get the Most from your Writer/Editor
Rick Bragg
Writing in Color
Jon Franklin
Beginning, Middle and End
Emily Hiestand
Big Ideas Hidden
Adam Hochschild
My First Great Lesson
Tom French
Serial Narratives
Jacqui Banaszynski, Jim Collins
Editing Narrative
Ira Glass
Showbiz Values in Journalism
Isabel Wilkerson
Honor Thy Subjects
Chip Scanlan
Storyteller's Toolbox

Jack Hart
Convince your Editor to Accept Narrative

Stan Grossfeld
Photos that Make a Difference